Cozy Apple Cider Old Fashioned: The Ultimate Fall Cocktail Recipe
Step into the enchanting flavors of autumn with this incredible Apple Cider Old Fashioned. It’s a delightful reinterpretation of the classic cocktail, infused with the warm, comforting essence of fall. Imagine sipping on a drink that perfectly balances the robust character of bourbon with the crisp, sweet-tart notes of fresh apple cider and a touch of caramel from brown sugar. This simple yet sophisticated beverage is just four ingredients away from becoming your new favorite autumn indulgence. Whether you’re unwinding after a long day or hosting a festive gathering, this cozy and refreshing cocktail is guaranteed to impress.
There’s something inherently comforting about a well-made Old Fashioned, especially as the days grow shorter and the air turns crisp. For my husband and me, it’s a cherished ritual, a staple in our home, particularly during the colder months when whiskey’s warming embrace feels most welcome. This seasonal rendition elevates the experience by incorporating the vibrant flavors of apple cider and the rich sweetness of brown sugar. Enhanced with thoughtful garnishes like fresh apple slices and aromatic cinnamon sticks, it transforms into the quintessential drink for fall festivities and holiday entertaining. If you appreciate the depth of a fine bourbon or are simply searching for a standout fall-themed cocktail to share with loved ones, this Apple Cider Old Fashioned is an absolute must-try!
Table of Contents
- What is an Old Fashioned Cocktail?
- Why This Apple Cider Old Fashioned is a Fall Favorite
- Essential Ingredients You’ll Need for Your Fall Cocktail
- Elevate Your Drink with Optional Garnishes
- How to Craft the Perfect Apple Cider Old Fashioned Cocktail
- Apple Cider Old Fashioned FAQs
- More Fall and Winter Cocktails You’ll Love
- Get the Full Recipe
“A delicious cocktail, even for someone who is not the biggest fan of bourbon. I used less bourbon and much more cider and it was delicious. I particularly liked the cinnamon stick, and found that if I stirred with it, I could taste the cinnamon. Thanks!” — reader Vivian
What is an Old Fashioned Cocktail?
The Old Fashioned is a timeless classic, often regarded as one of the original cocktails, dating back to the early 19th century. Its enduring popularity stems from its elegant simplicity and the ability to showcase the nuanced flavors of its base spirit. A truly classic Old Fashioned is built upon a straightforward foundation: a sugar cube (or simple syrup), a few dashes of aromatic bitters, and a generous pour of bourbon or rye whiskey. Traditionally, it’s gently stirred over a large ice cube in a lowball glass and finished with a twist of citrus rind, typically orange or lemon, to add a fragrant aromatic lift.
This enduring formula highlights the beauty of fewer, high-quality ingredients, allowing each component to shine. The sugar provides balance, the bitters add complexity and depth, and the whiskey takes center stage, delivering its unique character. It’s a cocktail that rewards thoughtful preparation and appreciation, a true connoisseur’s choice.
Why This Apple Cider Old Fashioned is a Fall Favorite
So, what makes our Apple Cider Old Fashioned so special and perfectly suited for autumn? We’ve taken the beloved classic and infused it with seasonal magic. The primary difference lies in the addition of a splash of rich, flavorful apple cider, which instantly transports your taste buds to an apple orchard on a crisp fall day. Instead of traditional sugar or simple syrup, we opt for brown sugar, which not only provides sweetness but also introduces delightful caramel undertones that perfectly complement both the apple and the whiskey.
This combination infuses the drink with a beautiful apple essence, enhanced by those warm caramel notes. When you top it off with our suggested seasonal garnishes like an orange twist, apple slices, or a cinnamon stick, you create a truly immersive fall experience. It’s a cocktail that feels both familiar and excitingly new, offering a cozy warmth while still being incredibly refreshing. It’s the ideal drink to celebrate pumpkin patch visits, Thanksgiving dinners, or simply to enjoy by a crackling fire.
Essential Ingredients You’ll Need for Your Fall Cocktail
Crafting the perfect Apple Cider Old Fashioned starts with selecting quality ingredients. Here’s a detailed look at everything you’ll need to make this delightful fall cocktail. For precise measurements, be sure to check the full recipe below. Keep reading for inspiring garnish options and suggestions to truly complete your drink.
- Quality Apple Cider: This is the star of our fall twist! For the best flavor, seek out fresh, unfiltered apple cider. You’ll often find it in the refrigerated section of your local grocery store, especially during autumn. If you’re lucky enough to live near an apple orchard, purchasing directly from them will provide an unparalleled depth of flavor. If fresh cider is hard to come by, “Simply Apple” juice is a widely accessible and excellent alternative that delivers a great, clean apple taste. Avoid apple juice concentrates or highly processed versions, as they won’t provide the robust flavor needed for this cocktail.
- Bourbon or Rye Whiskey: Since whiskey forms the backbone of any Old Fashioned, its quality significantly impacts the final taste. It’s crucial to choose a good quality spirit – this isn’t the time to reach for the cheapest bottle on the shelf. Bourbon offers a sweeter, smoother profile with notes of vanilla and caramel, which harmonizes beautifully with apple and brown sugar. Rye whiskey, on the other hand, provides a spicier, drier, and bolder kick that can add another layer of complexity. Experiment with both to find your preference! Excellent moderately priced options in the U.S. include Wild Turkey, Evan Williams, Maker’s Mark, and Elijah Craig.
- Angostura Bitters: A non-negotiable for any Old Fashioned, bitters are like the salt and pepper of the cocktail world. Angostura bitters are the ultimate classic choice, recognizable by their iconic oversized label and found in most grocery and liquor stores. They add a complex aromatic depth, with hints of spices like cinnamon, clove, and nutmeg, which beautifully tie all the autumnal flavors together. Don’t skip these; they are essential for balance and complexity.
- Light or Dark Brown Sugar: We use brown sugar to introduce those lovely caramel notes that complement the apple cider and bourbon so well. Light brown sugar offers a subtle molasses flavor, while dark brown sugar provides a richer, more pronounced caramel taste. Adjust to your preference! A note on sweetness: some readers have found that if their apple cider is particularly sweet and flavorful, they prefer to reduce or even omit the extra brown sugar. Taste as you go and adjust to your desired level of sweetness.
- Ice: While often overlooked, the quality and size of your ice matter. Large ice cubes or spheres melt slower, preventing your drink from becoming watered down too quickly. This ensures your Apple Cider Old Fashioned stays perfectly chilled and flavorful from the first sip to the last.
Elevate Your Drink with Optional Garnishes
Garnishes aren’t just for show; they enhance the aroma, flavor, and overall drinking experience of your cocktail. While not strictly necessary, choosing one or several of these garnishes will truly complete your Apple Cider Old Fashioned, adding that extra touch of fall elegance.
- Orange Twist or Slice: This is the signature garnish for a classic Old Fashioned, and it works wonderfully here too. The bright citrus oils from the orange zest provide a fragrant lift that beautifully cuts through the richness of the bourbon and apple, adding a refreshing counterpoint. To make a twist, use a vegetable peeler to remove a strip of zest, then twist it over the drink to release its oils before dropping it in or hanging it on the rim.
- Apple Slices: A natural choice for an apple cider-based cocktail! Thinly sliced apples (such as Honeycrisp, Fuji, or Gala) not only look beautiful but also add a subtle fresh apple aroma and flavor as you sip. You can fan them out on the rim or float them in the drink.
- Cinnamon Stick: For an unmistakable autumnal aroma and a hint of warm spice, a cinnamon stick is perfect. As you stir or sip, the cinnamon infuses the drink with a gentle, fragrant warmth. For an even more intense aroma, briefly toast the cinnamon stick with a kitchen torch before adding it. As reader Vivian noted, stirring with the stick helps infuse the cinnamon flavor directly!
- Luxardo Cherries: These aren’t your typical bright red maraschino cherries. Luxardo cherries are a premium Italian maraschino cherry, dark and syrupy with a rich, complex flavor that’s both sweet and tart. They add a sophisticated touch and a burst of fruit that complements the bourbon and apple beautifully. A single cherry at the bottom of the glass or skewered with an apple slice makes for an elegant presentation.
How to Craft the Perfect Apple Cider Old-Fashioned Cocktail
Making this Apple Cider Old Fashioned is incredibly straightforward, ensuring you can enjoy a sophisticated fall drink with minimal effort. Follow these simple steps for a perfectly balanced cocktail:
- Prepare the Base: In a sturdy lowball glass (also known as a rocks glass), combine your chosen apple cider, a dash of Angostura bitters, and the brown sugar. Using a spoon or a cocktail stirrer, gently stir the mixture until the brown sugar is fully dissolved. This initial step is crucial for ensuring a smooth, well-integrated sweetness throughout the drink. Take your time here; you want no grainy residue at the bottom.
- Add Ice and Bourbon: Once the sugar is dissolved, add a large ice cube or several smaller ones to the glass. Then, pour in your preferred bourbon or rye whiskey. Give the cocktail a light, quick stir – just enough to combine the ingredients without over-diluting. The goal is to chill the drink and meld the flavors, not to water it down.
- Garnish with Flair: Now for the artistic touch! While an orange twist is the classic garnish for an Old Fashioned, adding a fall twist is easy. Consider an elegant fan of apple slices, a fragrant cinnamon stick, or a rich Luxardo cherry. You can even combine them for a truly stunning presentation that enhances both the visual appeal and aromatic profile of your drink. The garnishes aren’t just decorative; they contribute to the overall sensory experience.
- Serve and Savor: Your beautiful and delicious Apple Cider Old Fashioned is now ready! Serve it immediately and encourage your guests (or yourself!) to take a moment to appreciate the aroma before taking the first delightful sip. Enjoy the perfect blend of cozy warmth and crisp fall flavors!
Apple Cider Old Fashioned FAQs
Transforming this delicious cocktail into an alcohol-free mocktail is wonderfully easy! For a refreshing non-alcoholic version, we suggest increasing the apple cider to 3 ounces and adding 1 ounce of sparkling club soda or ginger ale for a delightful fizz. Crucially, don’t skip the bitters; Angostura bitters contain a negligible amount of alcohol per dash (less than vanilla extract) but are essential for adding complexity and depth of flavor that mimics a traditional cocktail. And definitely include the garnishes! An orange twist, apple slices, or a cinnamon stick will still provide those wonderful aromatic cues and elevate the mocktail experience, making it feel just as special and festive as its alcoholic counterpart. You can also add a splash of non-alcoholic spirit alternatives if you wish for more depth.
For recipes like the Apple Cider Old Fashioned, where the spirit is a primary flavor, I generally recommend choosing a moderately high-quality bourbon or rye whiskey. This means something that’s not the absolute top shelf (and thus, most expensive) but also not the lowest in price. The quality of the whiskey will significantly impact the smoothness and overall flavor profile of your cocktail. In the U.S., some excellent and widely available brands that offer great quality for their price point include Wild Turkey (known for its robust flavor), Evan Williams (a solid, classic bourbon), Maker’s Mark (smooth with hints of vanilla), and Elijah Craig (a well-balanced, slightly spicier option). These brands provide a fantastic base that will allow the apple cider and brown sugar to shine without being overpowered, resulting in a beautifully balanced and enjoyable drink.
Absolutely! This recipe is perfect for scaling up for entertaining. To make a batch, simply multiply all the liquid ingredients (apple cider, bourbon, bitters) by the number of servings you need. Combine these ingredients in a pitcher or a stylish decanter. For the brown sugar, you might want to start with a slightly smaller proportion and taste, as collective sweetness can sometimes be more pronounced. Stir everything well until the sugar is dissolved. When serving, pour the pre-mixed cocktail over fresh ice in individual lowball glasses. Add your garnishes to each glass just before serving to keep them fresh and vibrant. This method allows you to enjoy your guests without constantly mixing individual drinks!
If you prepare a batch of the Apple Cider Old Fashioned (without ice or garnishes), it can be stored in an airtight container or bottle in the refrigerator for up to 2-3 days. The flavors may even meld and deepen slightly over time. However, for the freshest taste and best presentation, it’s always recommended to add ice and garnishes just before serving.
More Fall and Winter Cocktails You’ll Love
If you’ve enjoyed the warming embrace of this Apple Cider Old Fashioned, you’ll surely love exploring more seasonal sips perfect for the colder months and holiday festivities. Here are a few more delightful fall and winter cocktails to add to your repertoire:
Get the Full Recipe
Ready to mix up your own Apple Cider Old Fashioned? Here is the complete recipe card, including detailed measurements and instructions to guide you through crafting this perfect fall cocktail. Enjoy every sip of this cozy and crisp autumn delight!
Apple Cider Old Fashioned Cocktail
1
drink
5 minutes
Pin Recipe
Leave a Review
Ingredients
-
2 ounces
quality apple cider or juice -
Dash of angostura bitters -
½ teaspoon
brown sugar
(see Notes) -
2 ounces
bourbon whiskey -
Ice
, for serving
Optional garnishes
-
Orange slice or twist -
Apple slices -
Luxardo maraschino cherries -
Cinnamon stick
Prevent your screen from going dark
Instructions
-
In a lowball glass, combine the apple cider (or juice), bitters, and brown sugar. Swirl the glass or stir gently until the mixture is combined and the sugar is completely dissolved.
-
Add a large ice cube (or several smaller ones) and pour in the bourbon whiskey. Give it a quick, light stir to combine and chill the drink.
-
Top with your desired garnishes, such as an orange twist, apple slices, Luxardo cherry, and/or a cinnamon stick. Serve immediately and enjoy!
Notes
- Adjusting Sweetness: Some readers have found that if they use a naturally sweet and flavorful apple cider, the extra brown sugar isn’t always necessary. Feel free to reduce the amount or omit it entirely if your cider provides enough sweetness to your liking. Always taste and adjust!
- Batching for Crowds: This recipe scales up beautifully! You can easily double, triple, or quadruple the ingredients to prepare a larger batch in a pitcher. Mix the liquids and brown sugar (adjusting to taste) and chill. When ready to serve, simply pour over ice into individual glasses and add garnishes for a convenient and elegant party drink.
Calories:
172
kcal
,
Carbohydrates:
10
g
,
Protein:
1
g
,
Fat:
1
g
,
Saturated Fat:
1
g
,
Sodium:
4
mg
,
Potassium:
57
mg
,
Sugar:
9
g
American
Drinks
Annalise Sandberg
Have you tried this recipe?
I’d love to hear about it! Leave a rating and review below, or take a photo and tag it on Instagram @completelydelicious with #completelydelicious.
This recipe was originally published October 2013 and has been updated and expanded for clarity and comprehensiveness.